Economics

Defined Contribution

Published Apr 7, 2024

Definition of Defined Contribution Plan

A Defined Contribution Plan is a type of retirement plan where an employer, employee, or both make contributions on a regular basis, but the future benefits are not predefined. Instead, the benefits depend on the investment’s performance. This contrasts with a Defined Benefit Plan, where retirees receive a specific amount based on salary history and years of service. Popular examples of Defined Contribution Plans include 401(k) plans in the United States and personal pension schemes in the UK.

Example

Consider an employee named Sara who contributes 6% of her monthly salary to her company’s 401(k) plan, and her employer matches her contribution. Both these amounts are invested in various securities. Over the years, the value of these investments will rise and fall based on market performance. When Sara retires, the amount available to her from the plan will be the total sum of contributed money plus or minus any investment gains or losses over the years. Hence, the risk of investment is borne largely by Sara, the employee.

At retirement, Sara’s benefits will not be a fixed amount but will depend on the total value of her account within the 401(k) plan. This makes the Defined Contribution Plan more flexible but also introduces a degree of uncertainty regarding retirement benefits.

Why Defined Contribution Plans Matter

Defined Contribution Plans have become increasingly popular due to their lower costs and the shifting of investment risk from the employer to the employee. They also offer greater flexibility for employees, as many plans allow the selection of investment choices based on risk tolerance and retirement goals. Additionally, they often provide portability, meaning employees can move their plan assets from one employer to another when changing jobs, without losing their accrued benefits.

For employers, these plans are easier and less costly to administer compared to Defined Benefit Plans. They don’t have to bear the investment risk or promise a specific payout at retirement, which can be financially demanding.

For society, the shift toward Defined Contribution Plans raises concerns about the adequacy of retirement savings. Since outcomes depend greatly on investment performance and individual contribution rates, there’s a risk that a significant portion of the workforce might not save enough for retirement. This shift highlights the importance of financial literacy and planning for all working individuals.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What are the main differences between Defined Contribution Plans and Defined Benefit Plans?

Defined Contribution Plans, such as a 401(k), do not promise a specific benefit at retirement. The retirement benefits depend on contributions and investment performance. Defined Benefit Plans, however, provide a guaranteed payout, typically based on salary and years of service, regardless of investment performance.

How can participants maximize their benefits from a Defined Contribution Plan?

Participants can maximize their benefits by contributing consistently, taking full advantage of any employer matching contributions, selecting appropriate investment options based on their risk tolerance and retirement timeline, and regularly reviewing and adjusting their investment choices as needed.

What happens to a Defined Contribution Plan if an employee changes jobs?

Most Defined Contribution Plans offer portability, meaning the employee can move their accumulated savings to their new employer’s plan or into an individual retirement account (IRA) without penalty. This flexibility is a key advantage of Defined Contribution Plans, allowing employees to maintain their retirement savings momentum throughout their career changes.

Defined Contribution Plans present a modern approach to retirement savings, emphasizing personal responsibility, investment involvement, and flexibility. While they offer advantages like portability and potentially higher retirement savings, they also require individuals to be more proactive and informed about their retirement planning and investment options.